10 Shows like Mindhunter for Crime Thriller Enthusiasts

If you’re a fan of the gripping crime thriller series Mindhunter, then you’re probably craving more shows that delve into the dark and twisted minds of criminals. In this article, we have curated a list of 10 shows like Mindhunter that will satisfy your craving for psychological mysteries, intricate investigations, and intense character studies.

These shows share Mindhunter’s penchant for delving deep into the psychology of both the perpetrators and the detectives, offering a chilling glimpse into the minds of serial killers and the relentless pursuit of justice.

Best Shows like Mindhunter

From compelling narratives to brilliant performances, each of these shows delivers a unique and enthralling viewing experience that will leave you captivated from start to finish.

So, get ready to dive into these gripping crime dramas and unravel the secrets that lie within the minds of criminals with our list of top 10 shows like Mindhunter.

1. Fargo (2014–2023)

Shows like Mindhunter: Fargo

In first place on our list of best TV shows like Mindhunter is “Fargo”. It’s a unique and captivating TV series that stands on its own, separate from the original Coen film. The show introduces new, eccentric characters that rival the beloved Coen creations.

Billy Bob Thornton’s portrayal of ‘Lorne Malvo’ in the first season is particularly remarkable and has the potential to become a cult favorite. The series masterfully depicts how bad decisions and unfortunate circumstances lead ordinary lives down a dark and violent path, all while maintaining a wicked sense of humor.

Each season features a new cast and storyline, allowing for fresh and outstanding performances. The production values, especially the cinematography, are exceptional.

While the show’s quirkiness and non-mainstream style may not resonate with everyone, fans of black comedies and the Coen brothers’ work will thoroughly enjoy this pitch-black and entertaining series.

2. True Detective Season 1 (2014)

Shows like Mindhunter: True Detective Season 1

“True Detective” season 1 is a compelling crime drama that follows the investigation of a disturbing murder case by two Louisiana detectives, Marty Hart and Rust Cohle.

The series skillfully weaves between the 1995 crime and present-day interviews, gradually unraveling a complex plot involving potential victims and suspects. While the pace may be slow for those seeking fast-paced action, the show remains gripping throughout.

The character development is exceptional, with Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey delivering standout performances. McConaughey’s portrayal of Cohle, in particular, showcases his versatility as the character evolves over time. The Louisiana scenery adds to the show’s atmospheric appeal, almost becoming a character itself.

As the story nears its conclusion, it incorporates elements of horror, keeping viewers on edge. “True Detective” season 1 is a must-watch series for fans of shows like Mindhunter.

3. Hannibal (2013–2015)

Shows like Mindhunter: Hannibal

“Hannibal” defies expectations and delivers a captivating experience for fans of Thomas Harris’ novels and the iconic films. Despite initial reservations about revisiting the story and a standout performance by Anthony Hopkins, Mads Mikkelsen’s portrayal of Hannibal Lecter proves to be a revelation.

The series cleverly plays with familiar storylines, keeping viewers on edge with unexpected twists and liberties taken. The dynamic between Mikkelsen’s Hannibal and Hugh Dancy’s Will Graham creates a thrilling cat-and-mouse game that is a joy to watch, fueled by surgically precise writing.

Visually, “Hannibal” stands apart with its opulent and artistic aesthetic. The imagery draws inspiration from oil paintings and Dutch Baroque still lifes, adding a unique and visually captivating layer to the show’s crime narrative.

While the series is undeniably gory, it combines this element with stunning visuals, fascinating characters, and an exceptional cast.

“Hannibal” is a crime show like no other, pushing boundaries and offering an unparalleled visual experience for fans shows similar to Mindhunter.

4. American Crime Story (2016– )

Shows like Mindhunter: American Crime Story

Ryan Murphy’s transition into the true crime genre with “American Crime Story” has been nothing short of brilliant. Each season, from “The People vs. O.J. Simpson” to “Gianni Versace” and now “Impeachment,” showcases Murphy’s expertise in writing, casting, and production.

Venturing into real events while maintaining a flawless production is no easy feat, but Murphy succeeds with flying colors. He demonstrates his mastery of visualizing American culture, portraying it in its correct timeline with sensitivity and depth. The storytelling is captivating, leaving viewers eager to turn the page and discover what unfolds next.

Murphy’s ability to present each tale without overwhelming or passing judgment is commendable. “American Crime Story” stands as a testament to his skill in portraying real events, making them feel like a gripping novel come to life.

With each new season, Ryan Murphy continues to captivate audiences, and we eagerly anticipate the stories he will bring us next.

5. Broadchurch (2013–2017)

Shows like Mindhunter: Broadchurch

‘Broadchurch’ is a visually stunning series that captivates viewers with its gripping mystery and intelligent writing. The atmospheric locations and beautiful cinematography enhance the brooding tone of the show, while the haunting and tragic music further adds to its impact.

The writing of ‘Broadchurch’ stands out for its layered and meaty storytelling. The series intelligently explores complex themes and delivers multi-layered cases that keep viewers engaged. The pacing is deliberate, yet the tension and mystery never waver, ensuring a gripping viewing experience.

The well-developed characters, both lead and supporting, are never black and white, showcasing redeeming qualities and flaws.

The performances in ‘Broadchurch’ are exceptional. Olivia Coleman delivers a nuanced portrayal, bringing a range of emotions to her role. David Tennant’s acting is among the best of his career, adding conflict and likability to his flawed character.

The supporting cast, including David Bradley, Pauline Quirke, Jodie Whittaker, and Charlotte Rampling, deliver standout performances.

Overall, ‘Broadchurch’ deserves its acclaim as a series that excels visually, narratively, and in its performances. It is without a doubt one of the best series like Mindhunter.

6. The Act (2019)

Shows like Mindhunter: The Act

“The Act” provides a fascinating and accurate portrayal of the disturbing mental condition known as Munchausen by Proxy, based on true characters and incidents.

This series sheds light on generational child abuse and its consequences, as it delves into the story of Dee Dee Blanchard and her daughter Gypsy Rose Blanchard.

Patricia Arquette delivers a mesmerizing performance as Dee Dee, portraying the mentally ill mother with depth and conviction. Joey King impressively portrays Gypsy, capturing the complexity of her character, from her longing for a fairy tale romance to her realization of the damage caused by her mother’s manipulation. Callum Worthy portrays the disturbed Nick Godejohn with skill, adding to the series’ intrigue.

The supporting cast, including Chloe Sevigny as the suspicious neighbor Mel, delivers noteworthy performances. Throughout the series, viewers witness the progression of real-life events, which are both captivating and unsettling.

“The Act” is a series that shouldn’t be missed for fans of shows like Mindhunter, as it provides a gripping and accurate portrayal of a harrowing story, shedding light on the realities of Munchausen by Proxy and its impact on the lives of those involved.

7. Prodigal Son (2019–2021)

Shows like Mindhunter: Prodigal Son

“Prodigal Son” is a police procedural network show that revolves around Malcolm Bright, an FBI agent and the son of a notorious serial killer, Dr. Martin Whitly. The series explores the complex dynamics within the Bright family as Malcolm confronts his traumatic past and assists the NYPD in solving crimes.

Michael Sheen’s portrayal of Dr. Whitly adds a captivating and entertaining element to the show, and the interactions between Sheen and lead actor Tom Payne are a highlight. While “Prodigal Son” follows a familiar format, the presence of Sheen elevates the series and adds depth to the overall narrative.

With two seasons under its belt, the show provides an enjoyable and engaging watch, especially for fans of crime series like Mindhunter.

8. Black Bird (2022)

Shows like Mindhunter: Black Bird

In eighth place on our list of best shows like Mindhunter is “Black Bird”. This is a gripping and suspenseful TV show that boasts an exceptional cast, including Taron Egerton, Paul Walter Hauser, Greg Kinnear, Ray Liotta, and Sepideh Moafi, all delivering standout performances.

Egerton, in particular, shines in what might be his best role yet. The writing and storytelling in this series are top-notch, offering an engaging narrative that is based on a true story.

The plot revolves around a prisoner who strikes a deal to secure an early release by entering a maximum-security prison for the criminally insane and extracting a confession from a suspected serial killer.

The intense thriller aspect keeps viewers on the edge of their seats, especially considering the real-life inspiration. “Black Bird comes highly recommended for its captivating storyline and strong performances.

9. The Other Me (2019–2023)

Shows like Mindhunter: The Other Me

“The Other Me” is a captivating Greek TV series that serves as a non-direct sequel to the movie of the same name. Created by the talented team behind the film and produced by Cosmote TV, the series delves deeper into the storyline, taking place two years after the movie’s events.

Led by criminology professor Dimitris Lainis and his team, the plot revolves around the hunt for a serial killer who chooses victims based on the six labors of Theseus.

This show exceeded my expectations, delivering a high-quality viewing experience. The performances are outstanding, the plot keeps viewers engaged, and the cinematography is excellent. The director has skillfully crafted the series, and the soundtrack adds to the overall appeal.

“The Other Me” presents a complex and intriguing storyline. The show’s complexity is handled well, creating a captivating narrative.

“The Other Me” stands as one of the best Greek TV shows, easily rivaling productions from platforms like Netflix. The producers have done a commendable job, delivering a magnificent series, making it one of the best shows like Mindhunter.

10. Cardinal (2017–2020)

Shows like Mindhunter: Cardinal

“Cardinal” is a gripping Canadian mini-series that revolves around a serial killer targeting young boys and girls in a small northern township of Ontario. Lead detective John Cardinal, portrayed by the talented Billy Campbell, is convinced of the existence of the elusive serial killer, despite skepticism from others.

The show delves into Cardinal’s relentless pursuit to apprehend the perpetrator, showcasing his determination and expertise.

The series creates a dark and moody atmosphere, further enhanced by the exceptional performances of the cast. Campbell’s portrayal of Cardinal is a standout, embodying the character’s tenacity and single-mindedness. The dynamic between Cardinal and his new partner, Detective Lisa Delorme, played by Karine Vanasse, adds depth to the narrative.

While the show is engaging and well-executed, one drawback is the length of the episodes. Extending the six 60-minute episodes to three 120-minute installments would have allowed for a more immersive viewing experience, eliminating the need for a six-week wait to see the resolution.

Overall, “Cardinal” is a compelling series that keeps viewers hooked with its intriguing storyline and stellar performances. It deservedly rounds off our list of the best series like Mindhunter.